Peer Review

Review papers, build your academic reputation, earn DOI credit for every review.

Why Review on Artosphere?

DOI per reviewAdd to CV, Publons-recognized
Public reputationNovice, Scholar, Expert, Oracle
TransparentReviews published after decision
Meritocratic13+ reviews = Oracle (editorial board)

Papers Awaiting Review

No papers currently awaiting review.

All 14 published papers have been reviewed and approved.

Review Format

Reviews follow a structured format inspired by OpenReview:

Summary1-2 paragraph summary of the paper's claims and methodology
StrengthsWhat the paper does well. Specific examples.
WeaknessesIssues, gaps, or concerns. Constructive suggestions.
Questions for AuthorsClarifications needed before final decision.
VerdictApprove / Revision Needed / Reject
Confidence1-5 scale: how well you know this specific subfield

Reviews are stored on IPFS with a hash on-chain. They are hidden during the review period and published after the decision is finalized. Each review receives its own DOI.

Become a Reviewer

Sign in with your ORCID to start reviewing. You need Scholar tier (2+ correct predictions) to review papers.

Learn about reputation tiers